Supreme Court Update: Recreational Use Immunity

By Bob Anderton

-

Ever wonder why there are “no trespassing” signs in the middle of nowhere? Many landowners fear liability if someone is injured on their land. This means fewer areas for hiking, biking and other fun stuff.

The Washington Supreme Court recently clarified that those who let others access their land for free have little to worry about.

Under the common law, landowners owe a different duty of care depending upon the legal status of the person on their land. One can be an invitee, a licensee or a trespasser. Landowners have the fewest duties to a trespasser and the most to an invitee.

Historically, people were considered invitees when they entered land for recreational purposes whether or not they were actually invited. This meant that landowners had a duty to perform inspections, to discover dangerous conditions, and to use “ordinary care” to keep their land “reasonably safe.”

While not especially onerous, these duties make people nervous. And, “No Trespassing” signs are cheap.

Legislation enacted in 1967 limited landowner liability. Over the years, this law has changed a bit, but the intent to encourage access to land for recreation remains.

RCW 4.24.210 says:

Any public or private landowners ... who allow members of the public to use them for the purposes of outdoor recreation ... without charging a fee ... shall not be liable for unintentional injuries to such users.

This statute flipped the common law rule. Now landowners are rarely liable for injured recreational users.

In September of 2001, the Washington Supreme Court clarified this third exception in Davis v. State of Washington. Davis rode his motorcycle off a 20 to 30 foot cliff in natural sand dunes owned by the state in which people are permitted to use recreation vehicles. Davis landed on his back and suffered paraplegia and blindness. Davis had been following tracks and there was an optical illusion that made it look as though there was no drop off. There were no warning signs, despite the fact that the area was mostly flat.

The Court explained that an injured recreational user must prove all four elements in the injury-causing condition or the landowner is not liable.

These elements are: 1) known; 2) dangerous; 3) artificial; and 4) latent. In Davis, the issue was whether the condition was artificial.

The Court ruled that, while the tracks leading to the cliff were artificial because they were a human-made alteration, this alteration did not transform the natural state of the thing that caused the injury—namely, the cliff. The test for liability is now whether “the artificial external circumstance so changed a natural condition [that] it is unreasonable to distinguish the two when analyzing whether the condition was artificial.”
This ruling should make landowners more willing to allow access to their lands. If there are questionable areas, warning signs might better protect landowners from liability than no trespassing signs.

At Anderton Law Office, we represent injured people, not landowners. Still, we want people to have access to private land for recreation. This decision makes good public policy and is a logical interpretation of the statute.

Content by Bob Anderton,
Attorney at Law


This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 2.5 License.

Fine Print Explaination
The following information is intended to assist humans find Washington Bike Law via machine enabled searches. There is no hidden text.

Bike Lawyer Bob Anderton Washington State Practice Areas
bicycle injuries, personal injury, wrongful death, products liability cases, accidents, crashes and collisions involving bikes, bicycles, fixies, tandems, scooters, skateboards, pedestrians, wheelchairs, mopeds, motor scooters, motorcycles, cars, trucks, and even the dreaded SUV. Unsafe premises, unsafe places, unfair insurance practices, bad faith, court-approved settlement guardian ad litem in King County, Housing Justice Project.

Bike Lawyer Dave Catechi Washington State Practice Areas
bicycle injuries, personal injury, wrongful death, products liability cases, accidents, crashes and collisions involving bikes, bicycles, fixies, tandems, scooters, skateboards, pedestrians, wheelchairs, mopeds, motor scooters, motorcycles, cars, trucks, and even the dreaded SUV. Unsafe premises, unsafe places, unfair insurance practices, bad faith.

Bob Anderton, Attorney at Law, Dave Catechi, Attorney at law, Anderton Law Office Seattle Bike Lawyers Serve Washington State Adams, Asotin, Benton, Chelan, Clallam, Clark, Columbia, Cowlitz, Douglas, Ferry, Franklin, Garfield, Grant, Grays Harbor, Island, Jefferson, King, Kitsap, Kittitas, Klickitat, Lewis, Lincoln, Mason, Okanogan. Pacific, Pend Oreille, Pierce, San Juan, Skagit, Skamania, Snohomish, Spokane, Stevens, Thurston, Wahkiakum, Walla Walla, Whatcom, Whitman, and Yakima. Aberdeen, Airway Heights, Albion, Algona, Almira, Anacortes, Arlington, Asotin, Auburn, Bainbridge Island, Battle Ground, Beaux Arts Village, Bellevue, Bellingham, Benton City, Bingen, Black Diamond, Blaine, Bonney Lake, Bothell, Bremerton, Brewster, Bridgeport, Brier, Buckley, Bucoda, Burien, Burlington, Camas, Carbonado, Carnation, Cashmere, Castle Rock, Cathlamet, Centralia, Chehalis, Chelan, Cheney, Chewelah, Clarkston, Cle Elum, Clyde Hill, Colfax, College Place, Colton, Colville, Conconully, Concrete, Connell, Cosmopolis, Coulee City, Coulee Dam, Coupeville, Covington, Creston, Cusick, Darrington, Davenport, Dayton, Deer Park, Des Moines, DuPont, Duvall, East Wenatchee, Eatonville, Edgewood, Edmonds, Electric City, Ellensburg, Elma, Elmer City, Endicott, Entiat, Enumclaw, Ephrata, Everett, Everson, Fairfield, Farmington, Federal Way, Ferndale, Fife, Fircrest, Forks, Friday Harbor, Garfield, George, Gig Harbor, Gold Bar, Goldendale, Grand Coulee, Grandview, Granger, Granite Falls, Hamilton, Harrah, Harrington, Hartline, Hatton, Hoquiam, Hunts Point, Ilwaco, Index, Ione, Issaquah, Kahlotus, Kalama, Kelso, Kenmore, Kennewick, Kent, Kettle Falls, Kirkland, Kittitas, Krupp, La Center, La Conner, Lacey, LaCrosse, Lake Forest Park, Lake Stevens, Lakewood, Lamont, Langley, Latah, Leavenworth, Liberty Lake, Lind, Long Beach, Longview, Lyman, Lynden, Lynnwood, Mabton, Malden, Mansfield, Maple Valley, Marcus, Marysville, Mattawa, McCleary, Medical Lake, Medina, Mercer Island, Mesa, Metaline, Metaline Falls, Mill Creek, Millwood, Milton, Monroe, Montesano, Morton, Moses Lake, Mossyrock, Mount Vernon, Mountlake Terrace, Moxee, Mukilteo, Naches, Napavine, Nespelem, Newcastle, Newport, Nooksack, Normandy Park, North Bend, North Bonneville, Northport, Oak Harbor, Oakesdale, Oakville, Ocean Shores, Odessa, Okanogan, Olympia, Omak, Oroville, Orting, Othello, Pacific, Palouse, Pasco, Pateros, Pe Ell, Pomeroy, Port Angeles, Port Orchard, Port Townsend, Poulsbo, Prescott, Prosser, Pullman, Puyallup, Quincy, Rainier, Raymond, Reardan, Redmond, Renton, Republic, Richland, Ridgefield, Ritzville, Riverside, Rock Island, Rockford, Rosalia, Roslyn, Roy, Royal City, Ruston, Sammamish, SeaTac, Seattle, Sedro-Woolley, Selah, Sequim, Shelton, Shoreline, Skykomish, Snohomish, Snoqualmie, Soap Lake, South Bend, South Cle Elum, South Prairie, Spangle, Spokane, Spokane Valley, Sprague, Springdale, St. John, Stanwood, Starbuck, Steilacoom, Stevenson, Sultan, Sumas, Sumner, Sunnyside, Tacoma, Tekoa, Tenino, Tieton, Toledo, Tonasket, Toppenish, Tukwila, Tumwater, Twisp, Union Gap, Uniontown, University Place, Vader, Vancouver, Waitsburg, Walla Walla, Wapato, Warden, Washougal, Washtucna, Waterville, Waverly, Wenatchee, West Richland, Westport, White Salmon, Wilbur, Wilkeson, Wilson Creek, Winlock, Winthrop, Woodinville, Woodland, Woodway, Yacolt, Yakima, Yarrow Point, Yelm, Zillah, and perhaps a few others.

Content Alternative Spellings
solistitur, solistitor, solister, solicitor, solicitors, barrister, barristers, barister, baristur, baristir, barristir, barristirs, barristur, judgement, judgements, barrester, leegal, leagal, leegel, leegal, clame, tryal, attourney, atourney, atourny, attourny, attornies, attornys, atturnies, lowyers, laywers, attourneys, attorneyship, lowyer, laywer, atturney, atturneys, lowyer, atorney, atorneys, aturny, atorny, legal advise, attroney, aawyres, exquire, esquire.

Site Content
personal injury, wrongful death, products liability, negligence, negligent, negligent conduct, fault, no-fault, at-fault, reckless, recklessness, outrage, strict liability, injured, disabled, disability, killed, maimed, hurt, fractured, wage loss, property damage, non-economic damages, economic damages, general damages, pain and suffering, special damages, plaintiff's personal injury, insurance, UIM, uninsured motorist, underinsured motorist, UIM, accident, accidents, crash, crashes, collide, collisions, bike, bikes, bicycle, bicycles, bicycling, biker, bikers, cycles, cycling, cyclist, cycle messengers, bike messengers, bike messenger, fixed-gear, fixie, fixed gear, mountain bike, track bike, cross bike, commuter bike, randonneurs, tandem bike, scooters, skateboards, pedestrians, wheelchairs, mopeds, motor scooters, motorcycles, cars, trucks, buses, trains, trams, boats, planes, ships, SUVs, rules of the road, sidewalks, parking lots, stairs, crosswalks, bike path, bike trail, bike paths, bike trails, sharrow, share the road, physically separated bike path, METRO, Burke-Gillman Trail, Duwamish Trail, Chief Sealth Trail, Interurban Trail, Myrtle Edwards/Elliott Bay Trail, Ship Canal Trail, Alki Trail, Bicycle Master Plan, Bicycle Advisory Board, Urban Trails, door, doored, doring, intersection, cross walk, cross-walk, zebra, yield, stop, T-bone, side-swipe, collide, police, unsafe places, premises liability, bad faith, unfair insurance practices, dog bites, litigation, trial, trial lawyer, arbitration, mediation, alternative dispute resolution, negotiations, settlement guardian ad litem, Washington bike law, Seattle bicycle accident attorney, Seattle bicycle injury lawyer.